Personal Insurance, Personalized for You

Life is full of surprises—but your insurance coverage shouldn’t be one of them. At Thomas L. May Insurance, we specialize in protecting what matters most: your home, your car, and your peace of mind. As an independent agency, we’ll help you find the right policy at the right price—so you can feel secure, no matter what life brings.

A black silhouette of a house on a white background.
A black and white silhouette of a car on a white background.
A black and white icon of a bus on a white background.
A black and white drawing of a jet ski on a white background.
A black and white silhouette of an umbrella on a white background.
A black and white icon of a briefcase on a white background.

Frequently Asked Questions

A black and white icon of a question mark in a speech bubble.

  • What types of personal insurance do you offer?


    We offer a wide range of personal insurance policies, including home, auto, renters, RV, boat, ATV, and umbrella insurance. Each policy is tailored to your specific needs—no one-size-fits-all plans here.

  • How do I know how much coverage I really need?


    That’s what we’re here for. We’ll walk you through your risks, assets, and goals to help determine the right amount of coverage—no upselling, just honest advice.

  • Can I bundle my home and auto policies to save money?


    Yes! Bundling is often a great way to simplify your insurance and save. We’ll compare multiple carriers to help you find the best combination of value and protection.

  • How do I file a claim through your website?


    We have provided the necessary links and phone numbers for all our carriers to make filing a claim as easy as possible.

  • What makes your agency different from buying insurance online?


    We offer something online-only providers can’t: personal, ongoing service from a local team that knows you. We’re here to answer your questions, update your policy when life changes, and make insurance feel a little more human.